Six Tudor Queens: Katherine of Aragon, the True Queen by Alison Weir

Six Tudors Queens - Katherine of Aragon I thought I’d read enough about the Tudors, but it seems that I was wrong. Despite having read about Henry VIII’s first wife, Katherine of Aragon, several times before, I was still able to enjoy this new fictional account of her life – the first in a planned series called Six Tudor Queens in which Alison Weir will devote one novel to each of Henry’s six wives.

Katherine of Aragon, the True Queen is a straightforward retelling of Katherine’s story, beginning in 1501 with her arrival in England at the age of sixteen to marry Prince Arthur, son of Henry VII and Elizabeth of York. The young Katherine is nervous and homesick but as the daughter of Spain’s King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella she is determined to accustom herself to her new country as quickly as possible and prove herself a worthy future queen of England. Her future is thrown into doubt, however, when Arthur dies just a few months into their marriage, leaving Katherine a widow.

In 1509 – after a long period of uncertainty – Katherine marries Arthur’s younger brother, Henry, who has just succeeded to the throne as Henry VIII. At first, Katherine is full of optimism; she and Henry are in love and looking forward to the birth of their first child, which they hope will be one of many. Unfortunately, the reader knows what is coming: a series of miscarriages, stillbirths and infant deaths (a daughter, Mary, would be the only child to survive), and the breakdown of Katherine’s marriage as Henry turns his attentions to Anne Boleyn. A story which began with so much hope and happiness ends in disappointment and heartbreak, but through it all Katherine stands by her conviction that she is Henry’s lawful wife and his one true queen.

As I said above, I have read other novels which tell Katherine’s story in fictional form, but this is certainly the most detailed and the most thorough. While most books tend to concentrate on Katherine’s later years and Henry’s mission to have their marriage annulled (which came to be described as ‘the King’s Great Matter), Alison Weir spends a lot of time on the period before they were married when Katherine, as Prince Arthur’s widow, was living at the court of Henry VII. I enjoyed reading about all the intrigue taking place within Katherine’s circle as her dowry of plate and jewels becomes the centre of a power struggle between strict Spanish duennas and manipulative ambassadors.

There were times, though, when I wondered whether this book really needed to be so long and so detailed. Alison Weir is a historian who writes non-fiction as well as fiction, but this is a novel rather than a factual biography and I think there were probably things which could easily have been left out to help the story flow better. Still, because Alison Weir does write so much non-fiction, I could trust that the background to this novel would have been fully researched and I had no problems regarding accuracy. However, there are a few controversies surrounding Katherine over which historians disagree, such as the question of whether her marriage to Arthur was ever consummated (Henry used this as the basis to his claim that his own marriage to Katherine was invalid). As Katherine is the heroine of the novel, we are asked to accept her own version of events (that is, that she and Arthur never consummated their marriage) and believe that she was telling the truth.

This is not an unbiased portrayal of Katherine, then; the whole novel is written from her own perspective, so we don’t hear anyone else’s side of the story. Because Katherine falls in love with Henry early on and continues to love him no matter what, she rarely attributes any blame to him – whatever he does is always the fault of someone else: usually Cardinal Wolsey, Thomas Cromwell or Anne Boleyn. It’s understandable, I suppose, that Anne Boleyn is very much the villain of Katherine’s story, but Anne will be the central focus of the second book in the series so it will be interesting to have a chance to see things from her point of view.

I thought this was an enjoyable start to a new series and I’m now looking forward to reading about the other five queens!

Advertisements

13 thoughts on “Six Tudor Queens: Katherine of Aragon, the True Queen by Alison Weir”

  1. I picked this up because I was curious to see what Alison Weir would do with the later queens and I wanted to start the series at the beginning. I thought I knew Katherine of Aragon well enough, but I enjoyed following her story, thinking about things again and empathising with her.

    1. I’m curious to see how she approaches the stories of the later queens too, particularly Anne of Cleves as she’s the one I know least about.

  2. I also love reading about the wives of Henry VIII. I’ve read one of Alison Weir’s non-fiction books and wondered if this series was worth it. I’ve always actually wondered about Catherine’s first marriage. I have a hard time believing it wasn’t, but find it strange that it only became an issue when Henry wanted out.

    1. It does seem very convenient – surely Henry should have questioned whether the marriage was valid before he went through with it, not just when he was looking for a way out. I suppose we can never know the truth!

  3. Overall I enjoyed this book. But I thought in parts it was too detailed, although with great attention to historical accuracy, which would have been more appropriate in a factual study rather than in a novel. In a novel it became tedious and too drawn out. But I am curious to read her next book about Anne Boleyn.

    1. I think the book could have been a lot shorter; it felt as though she was trying to include every little piece of information she had come across in her research. I did enjoy it, though, and am looking forward to the Anne Boleyn book.

  4. After all my studies about Henry VIII and my enjoyment of Wolf Hall, etc, this sounds like a great series for me. I am a bit dismayed by the comments about all the tedious details, but I think I will check it out. I did like your balanced review.

    1. The amount of detail did make the story drag at times, but it wasn’t a huge problem and didn’t stop me from enjoying the book. If you’re interested in the Tudors I definitely think it’s worth trying this series!

  5. You make a great point about Alison Weir and many other biographers/historians, that they tend to include too much detail. I haven’t read this one, but I’ve read some others of hers, and I would agree with you. This slows the book down.

    1. I’ve only read one of Alison Weir’s non-fiction books (her biography of Elizabeth of York) and I found it very long and detailed too. It wasn’t such a problem with the biography, but not really necessary in a novel.

Please leave a comment. Thanks!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s